1. Torture, assassination and blackmail in modern, asymmetric conflict; 2. Friends, foes or brothers in arms? The puzzle of combatant equality; Part I. Dilemmas and Paradoxes of Combatancy: 3. Shooting to kill: the paradox of prohibited weapons; 4. Shooting to stun: the paradox of nonlethal warfare; 5. Murder, self-defense or execution? The dilemma of assassination; 6. Human dignity or human life: the dilemmas of torture; Part II. Dilemmas and Paradoxes of Noncombatancy: 7. Blackmailing the innocent: the dilemma of noncombatant immunity; 8. Killing the innocent: the dilemma of terror; 9. Risking our lives to save others: the paradox (and dilemma) of humanitarian intervention; Conclusion: 10. Torture, assassination and blackmail: new norms for asymmetric conflict?
A practical guide for policy makers, military officers, students, and anyone else interested in asymmetric conflicts.
Michael L. Gross is Professor of Political Science and Chair of the Department of International Relations at the University of Haifa. He is the author of Ethics and Activism: The Theory and Practice of Political Morality and Bioethics and Armed Conflict: Moral Dilemmas of Medicine and War.
'Gross is known for bringing a sharp intellect and a keen moral
sense to the perplexing character of modern war. In his latest
book, he considers the prominent role of civilians in contemporary
conflicts - including wars initiated to protect the welfare of
oppressed civilians and those in which enemies use noncombatants as
shields or targets ... Gross' wariness of dogmatism ensures that
there are no easy answers; this is a book that will keep you
thinking.' Foreign Affairs
'Gross writes fluently, with a wealth of realistic examples ... He makes many interesting observations ... and he shows sensitivity to the complexities of modern armed conflict ...' The Journal of Ethics and International Affairs
"Michael Gross has written a thoughtful, lucid book about the dilemma of 'asymmetric conflict,' as when a nation confronts a terrorist movement or other insurgency that does not observe the laws of war and, more important, does not have a structure or employ tactics against which conventional military force is fully effective. To be limited in fighting such a group by the conventional laws of war is to fight terror and insurrection with one hand tied behind one's back; and, depending on the gravity of the threat posed by such a group, the question becomes how far if at all the nation should depart from the conventional rules of armed combat. The need to balance military necessity with humanitarianism, with regard to such practices as brutal interrogation, assassination, and disabling but nonlethal gas, is the theme of the book; and as Gross states in the conclusion, 'dogmatism is not the answer." - Richard Posner, Judge, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit
"This is a must-read book for everyone interested in the question of morality and modern war. Gross's focus, asymmetric warfare, is the new face of armed conflict. In contrast to other authors who have written on various aspects of this subject, Gross's treatment includes all the significant ways in which this kind of war is different from the models assumed in the law of armed conflict and in most moral analysis, including changes in the meaning of combatancy and noncombatancy, implications for prohibited weapons and for nonlethal ones, modes of warfare including terrorism, torture, and assassination, and asymmetric warfare in the case of humanitarian intervention. His analysis and argument are thorough, insightful, and challenging. Readers may disagree with Gross's conclusions on various issues, but the importance of this book is that it establishes a baseline from which both agreement and disagreement can point towards better thinking about the moral parameters of such warfare and possible changes in the law of armed conflict." - James Turner Johnson, Rutgers University
"Discusses ways of reconciling new forms of warfare with international law, including what is termed "targeted killing" and "enhanced interrogation." --The Chronicle of Higher Education
"Gross is known for bringing a sharp intellect and a keen moral sense to the perplexing character of modern war... In this book, Gross considers the prominent role of civilians in contemporary conflicts -- including wars initiated to protect the welfare of oppressed civilians and those in which enemies use noncombatants as shields or targets... this is a book that will keep you thinking." --Lawrence D. Freedman, Foreign Affairs [May/June 2010]
"....In this important book, Gross (Univ. of Haifa, Israel) explores the moral dilemmas of postmodern war, focusing on such issues as targeted killing, torture, terrorism, and the use of nonlethal weapons.... This clearly written book will be of general interest to students and scholars of international political ethics and military security and of special concern to government officials responsible for national security policy in the postmodern era.... Highly recommended...." --M. Amstutz, Wheaton College, CHOICE
"...With Moral Dilemmas of Modern War, Gross has offered the reader an introduction to the dilemmas facing us in an age where warfare is no longer relegated to skirmishes between national powers but consists of `wars of occupation, the war on terror, and wars against rogue regimes' (x).... Gross offers an important window-one comprehensive in scope-onto these dilemmas, his voice is invaluable in the discourse." --Jacob Held, University of Central Arkansas, Philosophy in Review
"...readers will find the moral model Gross proposes ultimately satisfactory, the book is immensely helpful for the depth and nuance it brings to the ethical discussion of the dilemmas of war in an era of asymmetric conflict." --Daniel M. Bell, Jr., Lutheran Theological Southern Seminary, The International Journal of Public Theology