|
Reviews
3.0
out of 5 based on
38
reviews.
– Customer review on 03/03/2010
In summary. The title character is not the main character, and this is not a murder mystery novel.
Like many others here I bought this book (and indeed the series) based upon the fantastic reviews it received. And whilst it is an enjoyable read, it does not deserve the littany of praises it has been receiving. It is a sound novel, written simply, which is engrosing enough to flick through the pages. The free flowing style and creative assembly of the main characters keeps you interested. But as a crime/detective/who-dun-it it fails miserably. With a cast of 20+ characters, only 3 are actually fleshed out. And as another reviewer pointed out, the first half is more a study in geneology rather than a crime drama. The title heroine is lacking in soul, feeling, ability, and is contradictory in actions and development. Nothing makes sense with her, but that still doesn't detract from her character, it just makes her not enjoyable as the main character. In fact she isn't.
Without giving anything away the solution to the crime is contrived and contrite, but at least the ending was worth a read, and that in itself does not a good murder mystery make.
This works better as a good drama, rather than a suspense thriller or crime story (as it is portrayed).
A thoroughly enjoyable and good read, but not the raving masterpiece that has had glowing reviews. Something to read when there is nothing else to read.
Was this review helpful? [ Yes]
or [ No]
4 person found this review helpful 1 did not
5.0
out of 5 based on
38
reviews.
– Customer review on 14/10/2009
One of the best thrillers I have read for a long time. It is a bit slow to start with but it inexorably draws you into a seedy and morally corrupt world. The writing is fluid and the pace just intensifies as the book develops. Lisbeth Salander is one of the most interesting characters invented in recent times. She is strong, street-wise, cyber-wise but you feel there is a vulnerability about her...until, of course, her revenge on the lawyer who is her state-appointed legal guardian.
Guaranteed if you read this one you will want to read book 2 in the series...and then there's always book 3.
Was this review helpful? [ Yes]
or [ No]
3 person found this review helpful 0 did not
5.0
out of 5 based on
38
reviews.
– Customer review on 19/11/2009
This is the thinking woman's crime thriller. The first 50 pages were a bit so-so, but then you're hooked in to the plot and the idiosyncracies of the characters. It was really difficult to put down. The twists and turns are never ending and keep you going right to the end, even though the main mystery is solved with 100 pages to go! I love a good whodunnit and this moves the genre up a notch or two. Scarpetta is banal compared to this. Such a shame there's only three to read.
Was this review helpful? [ Yes]
or [ No]
1 person found this review helpful 0 did not
4.0
out of 5 based on
38
reviews.
– Customer review on 09/02/2012
VqhbJh itcfxmmnzrzj, [url=http://mcxuzjyttaaa.com/]mcxuzjyttaaa[/url], [link=http://fpiaqxgxpsxe.com/]fpiaqxgxpsxe[/link], http://uojoqhmvgubl.com/
Was this review helpful? [ Yes]
or [ No]
4.0
out of 5 based on
38
reviews.
– Customer review on 25/01/2011
I read this series over the Christmas break. It was a fabulous holiday read and it kept me engrossed the whole way through. I will admit it - as with all three of the books - seemed to drag a little at the start but then things pick up by about half way through. The movie does not do the book justice - but... it would have been a 4 hour movie if they had included everything! I am not a crime fiction lover, but this one was pretty darn good!
Was this review helpful? [ Yes]
or [ No]
3.0
out of 5 based on
38
reviews.
– Customer review on 31/12/2010
I read through the other reviews with interest. Like most, I eventually got around to buying this book because of all of the hype and I admit I was a little underwhelmed. I thought I would be the only one to say so here.
While the story is not bad I found it to be lacking in character depth and was left wanting to know more about Salander. It felt like Larsson had trouble writing for a female character so took the easy way out by making her aloof and confrontational - lacking in any real dialect in many parts of the novel.
I found the setup of the story to be sound. Not the usual amateur criminologist stumbling over a major case but a journalist thrust into the case but a completely separate set of circumstances. Best described as a drama, page turner that would be a good pickup in an airport bookstore for a long flight. By no means the worst I have read but perhaps the hype has made some of us a little more critical than if we had just picked this up as an unknown title.
Was this review helpful? [ Yes]
or [ No]
5.0
out of 5 based on
38
reviews.
– Customer review on 17/08/2010
This award winning novel has worked its way into my top 10 list!
Captivating from start to finish you won't want to put it down as you engross yourself into the main character Lisbeth Slander. Definitely a must read, even if you aren't a "crime" reader..which i usually am not!! Enjoy
Was this review helpful? [ Yes]
or [ No]
5.0
out of 5 based on
38
reviews.
– Customer review on 29/06/2010
This will have you up half the night until you finish. Strong themes of violence against women which can be rather distasteful even if revenge is exacted in one instance in a very satisfying way. The book assumes the reader has some intelligence. I'm looking forward to the next two books in the Trilogy.
Was this review helpful? [ Yes]
or [ No]
5.0
out of 5 based on
38
reviews.
– Customer review on 07/06/2010
Believe the hype!
Disgraced Swedish finance journalist Mikael Blomkvist has just been convicted of libel, and is forced to resign from his post at Millennium magazine. Out of desperation, he agrees to an offer from Henrik Vanger, an ageing and reclusive industrial magnate. Vanger wants Blomkvist to write a history of the Vanger family but, more importantly, he wants Blomkvist to secretly investigate the disappearance of Vanger's grandniece Harriet, who has been missing, presumed murdered, for forty years. Harriet's disappearance has been tormenting Vanger for years, and the only clue has been a single flower sent to Vanger every year on his birthday.
Lisbeth Salander is an enigmatic and troubled investigator for Milton Security. Before hiring Blomkvist, Vanger uses Milton to conduct a background check on Blomkvist. When he discovers how thorough an investigator Salander is, Blomkvist hires her as a research assistant.
Together they dig into the murky past of the Vanger family, with Blomkvist's dogged investigating and Salander's meticulous research quickly turning up new leads. As they work closely together, the older Blomkvist starts to get under the young, tattooed investigator's skin, and they develop an interesting relationship. Each starts to feel a personal obligation to solve this mystery, but for very different reasons.
The book does take some time to get going. The skeletons in the Vanger family closet are laid bare, and the reasons for Blomkvist ending up in court are fleshed out as Vanger uses them as leverage against Blomkvist. Salander's unique past is also revealed, although not to Mikael. But once it does get going, it rockets! The conclusion is fast-paced, clever and satisfying.
Was this review helpful? [ Yes]
or [ No]
5.0
out of 5 based on
38
reviews.
– Customer review on 22/05/2010
The girl with the dragon tattoo has the ability to draw people in so far that they put the book down and realise they have read through the whole night - The authors ability to articulately describe every minute detail makes you feel as if you are a character in the book trying to solve the mystery - definitely a book to read and own.
Was this review helpful? [ Yes]
or [ No]
38 reviews, showing 1 to 10 
Review this Product
   Browse by Subject
  Webmasters, Bloggers & Website Owners
You can earn a 5% commission by selling The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo paperback book on your website. It's easy to get started - we will give you example code. After you're set-up, your website can earn you money while you work, play or even sleep!
 Authors/Publishers
Are you the Author/Publisher? Improve sales by submitting additional information on this title.
 |